On December 1st, there was a debate about climate change pitting Elizabeth May and George Monbiot against Bjorn Lomborg and Lord Nigel Lawson, at the Munk Centre.
The debate was on this point “Climate change is mankind’s defining crisis, and demands a commensurate international response.”
One blogger followed up this debate with the title "May and Monbiot narrowly lose Munk Debate"
One of my favourite debating techniques is "Reductio ad absurdam", meaning to take a proposition and show that it leads to an absurd conclusion. I am not a debater in the formal sense, nor do I speak Latin, but this is my attempt to reduce a proposition to absurdity. The proposition is: "Be it resolved that that it is useful to debate climate change publicly". The absurdity is that we need another debate to decide who won the first debate.
Scientific method seems to always be at odds with debating methods. The scientific method has probably led to every technological advance humans have ever made, from fire and agriculture to walking on the moon. But debate has been dominant over scientific methods for a long time.
The problem with debate is that it favours the rich and powerful, it favours the status quo, it favours ignorance over knowledge. Debate has allowed religion and superstition to flourish. Debate has held back scientific advances.
In this Munk debate, the definition of the win (used by Contrarian) was based on the before and after surveys of the audience, indicating that more people were swayed by the opposition to believe their side. So, May and Monbiot started with 61% on their side and ended the two hour debate with only 53% support. Although it is still more than half, apparently the erosion of support is the key factor. So now we can hold a debate on whether this is a significant trend or not.
Secondly, the original resolution made the whole debate about whether climate change is mankind's defining crisis. If I had the choice of sides, and wanted to win the debate, I would choose the con side against May and Monbiot. Bjorn Lomborg took advantage of the resolution to argue that while climate change was bad, that it would be more efficient to simply feed starving people than to diversify our energy policy. I think that tactic persuaded several people to change their view, especially when you think of poor starving people compared to a warmer climate, and you compare the cost of feeding them to the cost of building wind turbines. I think it's a short sighted way to look at things, but that is the way most people seem to think.
If I was debating, all I would need to do is bring up any other crisis that overshadows climate change. How about this? Since mankind's stupidity is making climate change worse, I would argue that stupidity is mankind's defining crisis. That way I win the debate outright with something everyone can agree on.
Monday, December 14, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(2306)
-
▼
December
(302)
- Modification motor yupiter brushes
- No More Broken Promises Ever Again
- The Myth of Limitless High Priced Oil
- BMW Recalls 2008-2010 F650GS and F800GS Motorcycle...
- BMW Recalls 2008-2010 F650GS and F800GS Motorcycle...
- Bank Bonuses Again
- The most extraordinary motorcycle GPS mount (but d...
- Yamaha V-ixion Street Fighter modification pictures
- Yamaha V-ixion Street Fighter modification pictures
- Zen and the Art of Scientific Inquiry
- 2010 Honda VFR1200F Wallpapers
- 2010 Honda VFR1200F Wallpapers
- Honda CB300R-Honda Tiger 300CC Specification
- Honda CB300R-Honda Tiger 300CC Specification
- Ward Hawthorne 1938
- Ward Hawthorne 1938
- YAMAHA MIO Sporty Modification Low Rider the blues
- YAMAHA MIO Sporty Modification Low Rider the blues
- ~Monark Rocket 1951-1957
- Monark Rocket 1951-1957
- My Shifter + Hubs Bicycle Collections (Vintage)
- My Shifter + Hubs Bicycle Collections (Vintage)
- 2010 Honda CB Twister Specification
- 2010 Honda CB Twister Specification
- Honda Civic VTi-S Sport Car Tuning
- Honda Civic VTi-S Sport Car Tuning
- Vario Scooter Concept Modification
- Honda Blade Concept Modification From CBR600
- Honda Blade Concept Modification From CBR600
- Gambar Modif Satria F 150 Streetfighter
- Gambar Modif Satria F 150 Streetfighter
- Modifikasi Toyota Yaris Ceper Style
- Modifikasi Toyota Yaris Ceper Style
- Motorcycling in other Countries: Attitudes
- Gemballa Ferrari Enzo Sport Tuning
- Gemballa Ferrari Enzo Sport Tuning
- Modif green colour
- NEW 2010 HONDA CB TWISTER Release
- NEW 2010 HONDA CB TWISTER Release
- The Subliminal Message of Avatar 3D
- 2010 HONDA CB TWISTER PRESS RELEASE
- 2010 HONDA CB TWISTER PRESS RELEASE
- HONDA VFR1200F SPORTBIKE PICS
- HONDA VFR1200F SPORTBIKE PICS
- KAWASAKI NINJA 250CC FULL ORIGINAL BODY REVIEWS
- KAWASAKI NINJA 250CC FULL ORIGINAL BODY REVIEWS
- Swingbike Dodsun 1976
- Swingbike Dodsun 1976
- Raleigh Chopper Mk2 1975
- Raleigh Chopper Mk2 1975
- Raleigh Chopper Mk1 1972
- Raleigh Chopper Mk1 1972
- Raleigh Chopper Mk1 1970
- Raleigh Chopper Mk1 1970
- Raleigh Chopper Mk2 1973
- Raleigh Chopper Mk2 1973
- Raleigh Chopper Mk1 1969
- Raleigh Chopper Mk1 1969
- Some Titanic Delusions
- Putting the Christ Back in Christmas?
- Wallpaper Valentino Rossi Picture
- Ducati 1198R Corse Special Edition
- Ducati Hypermotard 1100 Pictures
- Ducati 848 Sportbike Wallpaper
- Ducati 1198S Pictures
- Ducati StreetFighter Picture
- Ducati Multistrada 1100 Motorcycle
- Casey Stoner Team Ducati
- Buell Firebolt XB12R Motorcycle
- Buell Ulysses XB12X Wallpapers
- Buell 1125R Wallpapers
- BMW G650X Country Side Motocycle
- BMW S1000RR Prototype Pictures
- BMW HP2 Motor Sport
- BMW K1300GT Wallpapers
- BMW F 800 ST Motorcycle
- Bimota Tesi 3D Best Pictures
- Bimota DB7 Oronero Motor Sport
- Aprilia Shiver 750 GT Sportbike
- 2010 Aprilia RSV4 Factory Motorcycle
- Aprilia Shiver 750 Picture
- Solving the Gun Problem Just in Time for Christmas
- Why Santa Feels Safer in Canada
- Motor Scooter Modification
- Scooter Electric Modified
- Y2K: Jet-Engine Motorcycles
- Y2K: Jet-Engine Motorcycles
- Scooter Modification Photo Collection
- Motorcycling: The Friendly Wave
- Yamaha Mio Modified New
- Toyota Yaris Modified new
- Modification mio with blue colour
- Matic From Kawasaki
- Matic From Kawasaki
- Now Shipping: Desert Dawgs Motorcycle Rain Guards ...
- First American Woman to Ride the Cannonball Run
- First American Woman to Ride the Cannonball Run
- How To Drive in Snow
- Honda CBR 600 Custom
- Honda CBR 600 Custom
-
▼
December
(302)
0 comments:
Post a Comment