From Globe and Mail article The answer's blowing in the wind, but not all of us want to hear it
Roy MacGregor
Monday, Jun. 08, 2009 12:00AM EDT
"Michael Lansbury is just one of many cottagers in the Upper Ottawa Valley attempting to block a wind farm that could mean as many as 60 of the giant windmills going up in the heart of what could be described as a Group-of-Seven postcard.
Mr. Lansbury at first didn't like the idea of going down to the dock with a morning coffee and having to stare at a horizon that would look more like a bad science-fiction set than dawn slipping over the high hills of the Canadian Shield.
That is undeniably a Not-In-My-Back-Yard response and Mr. Lansbury concedes the point easily, saying he is "motivated by selfishness to the extent that I don't want the countryside ruined."
But he also considers himself an environmentalist, living simply on the lake, believing in solar panels and even personal windmills - but not these behemoths."
Personally, I believe in getting away from coal fired power plants, and nuclear plants, and I am also in favour of diversifying our energy sources with some green non-polluting energy.
But there is a campaign being waged against wind power, that as this article mentions, is "undeniably a Not-In-My-Back-Yard" response. The anti-wind power campaign actually goes far beyond the NIMBY attitude, and also insists that there should be no wind turbines anywhere in Canada. There are further arguments about sickness from the noise of the blades and from the "dirty" electricity. Wind turbines kill birds and may block their migrations. They could lower property values. They may cause erosion of shorelines. They don't produce enough electrical power most of the time, because the wind is too low or too high. And the Government is stealing money out of our pockets to fund them.
If that was not enough, and apparently it isn't, consider this. The wind turbines in Europe are claimed by some anti-wind advocates to have never saved any CO2 emissions to this day. And now apparently some of the Europeans are rebelling against wind power too.
I hope I have not left anything out of the multi-fronted argument against wind power. At this moment I am not trying to debunk those arguments, although I have in the past looked into them and I think some might be weak arguments that are just put in there to help boost the anti-wind power cause. But for me, adding in weak arguments does not help, it just wastes my time while getting at the truth, and just reduces my patience with the rest of the arguments.
But I really want to examine the comment that wind farms destroy the countryside - specifically the "heart of the Group of Seven postcard countryside" where Michael Lansbury has located his cottage.
A group of seven postcard typically will be a few evergreen trees and some rocky landscape. Now I don't mean to put down the evergreen trees on rocks as an artistic vision, but I was born and raised in the Canadian Shield, and basically you have about 8 million square kilometers of that type of postcard "countryside" in Canada. Most of it is "inhospitable" as they say, and therefore sparsely populated. I highly doubt if Mr. Lansbury lives in the heart of this landscape. More like the fringes.
Most of the population of Canada lives huddled for warmth and comfort within 200 km of the American border. When they do travel north from the border area, they are shocked to discover this strange boreal forest with thin soil over bedrock. So they build cottages on it, especially beside one of the millions of lakes, and come back to admire the view every weekend. We have a freeway north of Toronto that gets jammed up every summer weekend with cars heading north.
I wonder if we have over a million cottages in the Canadian shield yet, if not it must be close. I have to admit that I do not find the cottages as attractive as the cottagers do. I am not bashing cottagers here, but just trying to put some balance in this argument against wind turbines. The most ugly aspect, in my opinion, of the cottages are the "Do not trespass" "Private property" "Keep out" signs you see around them. Some may be legitimate, and I suspect others are posted on public land, just because the cottagers can get away with it and they don't want the public anywhere near their property.
It's not just the cottages, of course, but the outboard motor boats screaming along trailing fumes behind. Now again, I like boats as much as anyone. But it's obvious that the wind turbines make less noise, cause less pollution, cause less erosion, kill less fish, kill fewer people, and - yes - look better than the boats. Motor boats have been banned from a few Canadian parks and lakes, which is probably a good idea. But they are allowed on most.
As for Mr. Lansbury's self-proclaimed environmentalism, was it just the Globe and Mail writer who made him sound phony? But let me just go with the statements made in the article as if they applied to any cottager. I would prefer if he had mentioned some real environmentalist's concerns. What does he do with his waste, personal and otherwise? Does he believe in air conditioners, outboard motor boats, big SUV's? Does he like bears and wolves living nearby? Does he have a lawn sprayed with pesticides? These are some environmental issues. Come to think of it, does Mr. Lansbury actually have any solar panels or does he just believe in them?
Anyhow, it's just to say that cottagers and I do not have the same sense of what is spoiling the countryside. And how about this for a compromise? Only put up the wind turbines in or near places where you allow motor boats to operate.
Thursday, June 11, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(2306)
-
▼
June
(192)
- Yamaha Mio 2009 Black Edition
- Truth and Flat Tires
- Fascism: Is it Left or Right?
- Yamaha Mio small wheel
- Honda CB 400
- Honda CB 400
- Suzuki Smash Ceper
- Suzuki Smash Ceper
- Suzuki Shogun Racing Modifikasi
- Suzuki Shogun Racing Modifikasi
- Bajaj Pulsar With Ducati Monster Style
- Bajaj Pulsar With Ducati Monster Style
- BAJAJ PULSAR 180DTSi STREET FIGHTER
- BAJAJ PULSAR 180DTSi STREET FIGHTER
- 2009 Benelli Tre-K 1130 Motorcycle
- Shogun FL125SP 2007 Modif
- Kawasaki Ninja N 250 R Simple Modify
- Modifikasi Honda GL pro Neo Tech
- Supra X 125D Retro Style Gambar
- Gambar Modifikasi Vario Kinclong
- Modifikasi Honda Blade
- Propaganda: Fear Mining
- Ktm motorcycles
- New Suzuki Skydrive LIMITED Edition
- Honda Blade Fighter Modification
- Honda Blade Fighter Modification
- Modifikasi Honda Supra X 125
- Honda Karisma 2002 Modifikasi
- Honda Karisma 2002 Modifikasi
- Modifikasi Motor Thailand
- Modifikasi Motor Thailand
- Trend Modifikasi 2009
- Trend Modifikasi 2009
- Matic Modification Contest
- Matic Modification Contest
- Modifikasi Jupiter MX
- Modifikasi Jupiter MX
- Modifikasi Skuter 2009
- Modifikasi Skuter 2009
- Honda Unique Modified
- Honda Unique Modified
- Royal Enfield Recalls 2009 Bullet Motorcycles for ...
- Motorcycle Pictures of the Week - Pauline and Zoo...
- Rossi 100 Win in Assen MotoGP
- Rossi 100 Win in Assen MotoGP
- Economics 101: A Slow Day in a Texas Town
- Suzuki SV650 Sport Bike
- Yamaha R6 Sport Bike
- Modifikasi Kawasaki Ninja 250R
- Harley-Davidson Street Glide -LHX 2009
- Pic of the week with a tattoo side note
- Yamaha Spark 135 Thai style
- I always feel like somebody's watching me...
- Roger Ebert: From My Cousin Vinnie to Bill O'Reilly
- Update On Bombing Iran
- Triumph motorcycles
- Motorcycle clothing
- Yamaha X1-R Black Edition
- 2009 Kawasaki Ninja ZX-6R Monster Picture
- Yamaha Mio Low Rider
- Honda Jazz i-dsi 2007 Modified
- Motorcycle helmets
- Volkswagen Beetle 1961 Extreme
- Kawasaki motorcycles
- New Honda Click Modified
- I'm back in the saddle again.
- Ducati motorcycles
- The Meaning of I Wasn't Born to Follow
- Honda CBR-150 Street Racing
- What's YOUR riding thing?
- Scooters
- Harley Davidson motorcycles
- Yamaha Mio Big wheel
- Minerva Scooter Sport Matic
- Minerva Scooter Sport Matic
- Modifikasi Minerva GTR 150 R 2009 Review
- Aprilia RS 50
- Motorcycle Pictures of the Week - Paul
- The BS Detector: Artificial Intelligence?
- The Theory of Evolution of Intelligence
- 2009 Aprilia RS V4 Best Picture
- Yamaha Nouvo Elegance thai style
- New Ducati desmosedici GP9
- New Ducati desmosedici GP9
- Most Expensive Motorcycle
- Most Expensive Motorcycle
- Yamaha motorcycles
- Bajaj Pulsar
- Bajaj Pulsar
- Skuter|Scooter 2009 Modified
- Skuter|Scooter 2009 Modified
- Suzuki Spin Low Rider
- Suzuki Spin Low Rider
- Suzuki motorcycles
- Obama Criticised by Some Leftists
- Yamaha X1-R Modified
- BMW Recalls 2009 K1300GT and K1300S Motorcycles fo...
- Chopper Cub
- Propaganda: Uncle Tom's Cabin
- Tattoo Zone
-
▼
June
(192)
0 comments:
Post a Comment